To be or not to be [brilliant]

Judge Kavanaugh is in line to replace Justice Kennedy on the US Supreme Court. The nomination dance is about to begin in full force. Critics will raise questions about past cases, judicial temperament, law and the judicial role; and supporters will point to his past accomplishments and the judge’s professed belief in judicial restraint [and general support of conservative causes and ideas]. There is one fact upon which critics and supporters will agree: he is brilliant. Not smart; not clever; not bright; not astute.

BRILLIANT (and yes, I pulled out a thesaurus for help).

This post is a confession on my part. I don’t know what “brilliance” means. I’ve met a lot of brilliant people in my life, but the reason I know they are brilliant is because they tell me so, or others tell me in their stead. And as soon I think I have a handle on what it means, one of our esteemed justices retires and I am back to square one. Let me explain.

Judge Kavanaugh is brilliant, which we know because we are told incessantly. What exactly qualifies him for the distinction is less clear. Here’s what we know: he is a graduate of Georgetown Prep, Yale College and Yale Law School; clerked for Judge Kozinski and Justice Kennedy; worked for the Justice Department and the White House; was a partner at Kirkland & Ellis; and served as judge on D.C. Circuit since 2006. He clearly checks all the boxes for a seat on the Court. But that’s not the question. The question is, is he brilliant, and what makes him so? I can’t tell.

For another recent example, consider Justice Gorsuch. Same story: Georgetown prep, Columbia University, Harvard law, and a Marshall Scholarship at Oxford, where he earned a degree in legal philosophy; clerkships with Judge Sentelle and Justices White and Kennedy; DOJ; judge in the 10th Circuit since 2006. And also brilliant.

So here’s what I have: brilliance lies in elite academic achievements and fancy clerkships and jobs post-graduation. That is, Harvard and Yale graduates are brilliant; lawyers at DOJ and the White House are brilliant; circuit court judges are brilliant. Or in fairness, maybe is the confluence of all of these. So a brilliant person is one with Harvard, plus fancy clerkships, plus a DOJ position, plus a judgeship on his resume. That must be it.

But then I go back to the spring and summer of 2009 and the nomination of Justice Sotomayor. To refresh our memories: Sotomayor was born in the Bronx of parents both born in Puerto Rico. She attended Cardinal Spellman High School in the Bronx and was valedictorian of her graduating class; attended Princeton University on a full scholarship and graduated summa cum laude and Phi Beta Kappa; and attended Yale Law School. She was an assistant district attorney in New York County and later became partner in Pavia and Hartcourt. She served as judge in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York from 1992 to 1998; and on the 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals from 1998 to her nomination to the Supreme Court in 2009.

She matches up fairly well on paper with both Gorsuch and Kavanaugh. But pundits and the legal community responded to her nomination very differently. Not only was she not “brilliant” in the traditional sense, she was “not nearly as smart as she seems to think she is.” Her qualifications for the seat were questioned openly. Critics accused President Obama of sacrificing “biography over brain.”

Unsurprisingly, the claims do not stand up to empirical analysis. Justice Sotomayor’s stint as appellate judge matched up with her peers as well as judges widely considered “brilliant.” More importantly, can any of those critics look at her body of work on the Supreme Court and consider her an exemplary justice, or at the very least, on par with all the others? And yet, “brilliance” was not a word used during her nomination, but the opposite was true. Something is amiss.

Here’s what I think is going on. Yes, merit is socially constructed. No question. This means, more crucially, that merit is not an intrinsic individual quality, akin to the way we think of IQs or personality traits, but a mark of status within a community. We cannot begin to think about “brilliance” outside of the communities within which the moniker is used. This is why Judge Sotomayor was never accorded the honor that the label bestows. She was an outsider, even as she achieved honors at Princeton University, honors that, incidentally, neither Gorsuch nor Kavanaugh achieved. But they didn’t need fancy labels for those in the community to know how brilliant they were. Who needs summa cum laude or Phi Beta Kappa to see those things “we” already “know”?

And yes, this also means that people of color, as outsiders, are swimming against the tide.  As Justice Sotomayor herself once put it, “I have spent my years since Princeton, while at law school and in my various professional jobs, not feeling completely a part of the worlds I inhabit. I am always looking over my shoulder wondering if I measure up.”  Or President Obama, who once told us of his “constant, crippling fear that I didn’t belong somehow, that unless I dodged and hid and pretended to be something I wasn’t I would forever remain an outsider, with the rest of the world, black and white, always standing in judgment,”

An applicant of color is seldom if ever “brilliant,” and becoming so is never easy. Some never do. This is true even for those people of color who dare become Supreme Court justices, or president of the United States.

Please follow and like us:
12 comments
  1. Hi, raceanddemocracy.com

    Let’s see how we can achieve better advertising result for your business.

    I would like to start by sharing with you a case study of a local campaign we ran for a Burger King franchise.
    Their budget was only $1200 and we got them $4,825 in value of sales!

    See how we did it – Click here https://www.conciergedigitalleads.com/uploads/sYvnOSwp/SuccessStories-ReachFrequency-BurgerKing.pdf to download the Burger King case study

    Our company runs full-service Facebook Advertising campaigns with guaranteed results for as low as $95 for a one-off campaign.

    Let’s talk today. Click here https://conciergeleads.youcanbook.me/ to Book a 15mins Free Consultation Now

    Our process is super short and easy

    1. We set up a 15min call in which we learn about your business
    2. On the same call, we can design a campaign and start running
    3. We do all the work – a 100%
    4. You can try us with a very low budget

    We do everything from writing the copy, designing the ad, set up, and delivery on Facebook, ongoing optimization and reporting.
    We deliver a FULL-service solution.

    Book a 15mins Free Consultation Now…Click here https://conciergeleads.youcanbook.me/

    Looking forward to talking with you.
    Thanks,

    Emily Van Garderen
    Client Management Executive
    Concierge Leads
    conciergeseoleads@gmail.com
    T. 844-899-9770
    5887 N 42ND Street Milwaukee WI 53209

  2. I notice that you do not have a proper sales funnel on site and … you’re leaving money on the table ☹
    You want to fix this, right?
    Change your focus because THE KEY TO ONLINE SUCCESS IS…
    Funnels. Not Landing Pages
    Your Landing Page is just a door way to your Marketing Funnel, you still need other systems to build your order process, one-click upsells, downsells, product fulfillment details, membership areas, webinar series, email autoresponders, and affiliate platform… Or, you can just use ClickFunnels to handle it all.
    View your analytics, edit your pages with the most powerful drag-and-drop editor, and publish live in seconds. Demo, details and a test account are availbale on page http://bit.ly/2jOL3nh

    To your business success,
    George – support team
    http://www.digitalproductselection.com

    PS: To be successful online, there are 2 essential tools that you HAVE to have… an email autoresponder, and Clickfunnels. The proper tehniques & strategies to use them both can be found in DotComSecrets book and I can send you a review copy for FREE – enter your shipping details here https://rebrand.ly/DotComSecrets-order-page

  3. Hello! raceanddemocracy.com

    We offer

    Sending your business proposition through the Contact us form which can be found on the sites in the Communication partition. Feedback forms are filled in by our software and the captcha is solved. The advantage of this method is that messages sent through feedback forms are whitelisted. This method increases the chances that your message will be open. Mailing is done in the same way as you received this message.
    Your business proposition will be read by millions of site administrators and those who have access to the sites!

    The cost of sending 1 million messages is $ 49 instead of $ 99. (you can select any country or country domain)
    All USA – (10 million messages sent) – $399 instead of $699
    All Europe (7 million messages sent)- $ 299 instead of $599
    All sites in the world (25 million messages sent) – $499 instead of $999
    There is a possibility of FREE TEST MAILING.

    Discounts are valid until June 10.
    Feedback and warranty!
    Delivery report!
    In the process of sending messages we don’t break the rules GDRP.

    This message is automatically generated to use our contacts for communication.

    Contact us.
    Telegram – @FeedbackFormEU
    Skype – FeedbackForm2019
    Email – FeedbackForm@make-success.com
    WhatsApp – +44 7598 509161

    Thank you for your attention.

  4. Hello! raceanddemocracy.com

    We make offer for you

    Sending your message through the feedback form which can be found on the sites in the Communication section. Contact form are filled in by our software and the captcha is solved. The profit of this method is that messages sent through feedback forms are whitelisted. This method increases the chances that your message will be open.

    Our database contains more than 25 million sites around the world to which we can send your message.

    The cost of one million messages 99 USD

    FREE TEST mailing of 50,000 messages to any country of your choice.

    This message is automatically generated to use our contacts for communication.

    Contact us.
    Skype live:contactform_18
    Email – ContactForm@make-success.com
    WhatsApp – +353899461815

  5. Convert your traffic into clients with Animated Explainer Videos
    Let?s face it. There?s only 1 reason you have a website. To generate business, Right?

    You already have traffic. Want to convert more of your traffic into customers?
    They say a picture is worth a thousand words. Well, an animated explainer video is worth much more.

    You are too busy to read paragraph after paragraph of words on a website. Time is money and the quicker you can explain your business in an entertaining way to your visitors, the easier it is to convert them into your client.

    Watch this short 3 minute video and you?ll understand why successful businesses like Google, Amazon, Walmart and more use animated explainers video to get their message across.

    junepanama2000@gmail.com
    https://youtu.be/qCRNKMRETVg

  6. Hi! We are working with businesses like yours to support them in the creation of excellent websites and mobile apps of any complexity and specification.
    If your CEO / CTO / CIO has plans to launch new digital resources or update existing ones (to iOS 13 for example), Aplana can be a valuable partner and assist in achieving those goals.
    Aplana was featured on the Clutch Rating List of the Top-200 Best Custom Software Developers 2018 in the world (you may google this information).
    Since 1999 we have launched over 1500 small and large IT projects worldwide. We deliver digital projects to US customers through our highly skilled software teams in Eastern Europe.
    This structure allows us to keep the cost for our services reasonable and justified while maintaining a quality of work that is exceptionally high.
    Please contact us if you have any technical RFP ( request@aplana.us ) or visit us at http://aplana.us
    to get more info.
    Please, accept our apology if it currently doesn’t apply to you.

  7. EVROSIS Technologies’s turnkey solutions: we customize our products and services to meet the exact requirements of our clients. At EVROSIS TECHNOLOGIES, our developers, engineers, and data scientists are experts in Financial Engineering, High Frequency Trading, Trading Platform & financial markets.

    Our competitive strengths: High Speed Networks Development, High Performance Computing, Deep Learning A.I., High Sharpe Ratio Trading models, and talented Quant Traders.

    You can Get custom Trading Solutions for any Exchanges/ECNs in The World or use pre-prepared Solutions and Profit from a state-of-the-Art Model. You will save Time and Money by Working with Us.

    Contact us and we will implement your needs.

    Kind regards

    Website : http://bit.ly/2Zy0Cjx
    Skype: support.evrosis
    E-mail : info@evrosis.com
    EVROSIS Technologies Ltd.
    130 Old Street, London, United Kingdom, EC1V 9BD

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Enjoy this blog? Please spread the word :)