What do Luka Modric and Affirmative Action have in Common?

Luka Modric is a soccer player for Real Madrid and the Croatian national team. He was the best player in this year’s World Cup, the engine that led Croatia to the final and the winner of the Golden Ball as the tournament’s outstanding player.

This is a remarkable ascent for a player who was voted by fans as the worst signing in the Spanish League when he moved there from Tottenham in 2012. He is now one of the favorites to win the Balon D’or, which recognizes the best player in the world.

But is he the best player in the world? Is he deserving of the award?

Years ago, I wrote about Toby Gerhart, a running back at Stanford University and a leading contender for the Heisman Trophy, an award for “the outstanding college football player whose performance best exhibits the pursuit of excellence with integrity.” Toby Gerhart had a slim chance to win, arguably because he was a white running back. Running backs are not supposed to be white. And quarterbacks are not supposed to be black. And in that piece, I posited that professors are not supposed to be Black or Latino.  In considering race as we make decisions, we are forced to confront these pervasive biases.

I remembered that piece when reading about Modric a few days ago. I have no idea whether Modric is the best soccer player in the world. I don’t even know what that means. What I do know is that Modric is a terrific player. I also know that he is one of a handful of players deserving of the award.

This is the affirmative action debate in a nutshell.

Far too many applicants can stake a reasonable claim for a seat at elite institutions of higher education. It is hard to choose among them. But critics of affirmative action get around this problem by simplifying the process and focusing on specific metrics that bolster their case, reason and contrary arguments be damned.  We see this dynamic at play in the recent debate over “specialized high schools” in New York City.  We equate merit and just deserts — and assign scarce public goods, in the form of seats in elite high schools — with a score in a single test that students take in 8th grade.  If only life, or political philosophy, were so easy.

This is what intrigues me about the Modric example. He is undoubtedly a great player, deserving of every award he receives. But so are many other players. Should the winner of the Balon D’or be the player who scores or assists the most goals, plays the best defense, or leads his team to trophies and titles? Or is deciding on the winner a complicated question, for which no right answer avails?

It must be the latter.   The same is true for NYC’s specialized high schools, for higher education, and life in general.

So yes, I am rooting for Modric to win the award, in the name of reason and judgment above simplicity.

Please follow and like us:
12 comments to “What do Luka Modric and Affirmative Action have in Common?”
  1. QRiJN7eHcbJaqvzu7Q4QuclSiT7lsH9GfvU238sBLlwHADPixVQeNf64wvnaMAzUg1VRJkrMy

    Hi, very nice website, cheers!
    Need cheap and reliable hosting? Our shared plans start at $10 for an year and VPS plans for $6/Mo.
    Check here: https://www.reliable-webhosting.com/


  2. Wow! This could be one particular of the most useful blogs We have ever arrive across on this subject. Actually Wonderful. I am also a specialist in this topic so I can understand your effort.

  3. I just want to mention I am beginner to blogging and absolutely enjoyed you’re blog. Most likely I’m planning to bookmark your site . You definitely come with fabulous stories. With thanks for revealing your web page.

  4. I just want to say I’m new to blogging and definitely savored this blog site. Probably I’m going to bookmark your blog . You amazingly have very good article content. Thanks a bunch for revealing your webpage.

  5. There are several posts to choose from near this, I do think taking there reference could experience made this spot or article really informative. That’s not me expression this information is negative. Simply I’ve got to pronounce how the info provided here was unique, merely to make it more in close proximity to complete, supporting with former information get been actually good. The points you will enjoy touched allow me to share really important, thus I will spot some of the information here to produce this actually good for entirely the newbie’s here. Many thanks for this information. Actually helpful!

  6. You are so awesome! I do not suppose I have read a single thing like that before. So great to find someone with a few original thoughts on this subject matter. Really.. thanks for starting this up. This site is something that’s needed on the web, someone with a bit of originality.

  7. I like your website.. great shades & motif. Performed people design and style this fabulous website yourself or even have people rely on someone else to make it work for you personally? Plz interact when I!|m looking to pattern by myself blog site plus would want to find out wherever u received this particular through. thank you

  8. Good post. I learn something new and challenging on sites I stumbleupon everyday. It will always be helpful to read content from other writers and use a little something from their web sites.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Enjoy this blog? Please spread the word :)